Technology That Changed Lives

33 Miners, 69 Days and a 21-Inch Capsule: The Engineering That Brought Chile's Trapped Miners Home

In 2010, 33 miners spent 69 days trapped 2,300 feet underground in Chile. A custom capsule, a drilling plan and space medicine helped bring them home.

By TechHorizonCityNovember 18, 202610 min read
ContentsThe Human StoryThe Technology Enters the StoryHow the Technology WorksThe Moment Everything ChangedWhat Would Have Happened Without the Technology?The Technology Behind the BreakthroughWhere the Technology Is TodayThe LimitsWhat Comes Next?ConclusionSourcesEditorial Disclaimer

On 5 August 2010, the main ramp into the San José copper mine in northern Chile collapsed. Thirty-three miners were left trapped 2,300 feet underground, and rescuers could not even talk to them.

For 17 days, nobody knew whether they were alive.

Then a drill probe that had been lowered into the mine came back up with a note taped to it, written in red ink. It said, in the words CNN reported, “We are fine in the shelter, the 33 of us.”

That was the easy part. The men were alive, but they were still under a mountain of rock, and the question was how to lift 33 people up through a tunnel with a diameter measured in inches. The answer took three drilling plans, a capsule narrow enough to fit the hole, advice from NASA engineers and physicians, and a great deal of careful work by Chileans. It ended on 13 October 2010, 69 days after the collapse, when the last of the men came up.

The Human Story

The first days were a search with almost no information. According to CNN’s timeline, 130 people were working on the rescue the day after the collapse, and a second cave-in blocked one of the paths rescuers were using. Chile’s president, Sebastián Piñera, travelled to the nearby town of Copiapó on 7 August.

The Smithsonian’s account of the search describes how small the target was. Rescuers drilled exploratory holes, and the boreholes were tiny. The note arrived on the eighth exploratory drill, on 22 August.

Underground, the men had survived by sharing small amounts of tuna and mackerel that were in the shelter, along with water, CNN reports. One of the NASA physicians who later advised Chile, Dr. J.D. Polk, said in a NASA oral-history interview that the miners’ shift leader had the men dig wells, and that this was what kept them from severe dehydration.

Once a second probe reached the shelter on 23 August, rescuers could relay communications and send down food and water. On 26 August the miners sent a video message to their families. On 29 August each man was given about 20 seconds to speak with family. And on 14 September, the wife of one trapped miner, Ariel Ticona, gave birth to a girl. Her name was Esperanza, Spanish for hope.

Meanwhile, officials had told the men that getting them out would be a lengthy process. CNN reports that rescue officials earlier predicted the date might be as far away as November or Christmas.

The Technology Enters the Story

Chile’s government did not bet on a single method. According to CNN, it ran three drilling plans in parallel.

  • Plan A used a raise borer, a machine normally used for drilling ventilation shafts, placed directly above the shelter.
  • Plan B used a Schramm T-130, a rig normally used for boring water wells. It drilled at an angle of about 80 degrees toward an area of the mine used as a workshop, a distance engineers estimated at around 620 metres.
  • Plan C used a drill normally used for oil, which needed to cut through about 600 metres of rock.

Plans A and B each needed two passes: a small hole first, and then a wider hole of about 26 to 28 inches.

Plan B arrived at the site on 3 September. On 17 September its first hole reached the miners, but it was only 12 inches wide and had to be widened. On 9 October, the widened hole broke through to the mine.

At the same time, a second problem was being solved above ground: what to lift the men in.

How the Technology Works

Drilling. A drill like Plan B’s works by rotating a bit on the end of a string of pipe and breaking up the rock in front of it. The manufacturer of the bits used in the final stage, Center Rock, described its drill as using four or five hammers powered by compressed air, each pounding the bit like a jackhammer while the drill rotates. That is the company’s own account, and it also says the cuttings were allowed to fall to the bottom of the hole, where the miners cleared them. Other equipment details varied between sources, so I have kept this explanation general.

The capsule. The rescue capsule had to travel through a hole of about 26 inches and carry one man at a time. According to the Smithsonian, which displayed the test capsule, it was 13 feet tall and 21 inches in diameter. The Smithsonian describes two matching capsules: Fénix 1, used for testing, and Fénix 2, which carried the miners. (CNN calls the capsule the Phoenix; the name is spelled both ways.) CNN reports that two additional capsules arrived at the site on 6 October.

The capsule was designed and built by Chileans. Clinton Cragg, the NASA engineer who worked on the project, said in his NASA oral history that a group of engineers from a Chilean Navy shipyard was one of four or five groups asked to submit designs. He said they had been given little guidance beyond maximum size limits.

The NASA advice. The Chilean government asked NASA for technical advice, based on the agency’s experience protecting people in hostile environments. A four-person NASA team (two doctors, a psychologist and Cragg, an engineer) was on site from 30 August to 5 September. When Cragg returned to the United States, he led a team of engineers at the NASA Engineering and Safety Center who wrote a list of suggested design requirements within days. In his words, the Chileans did the design and the building, and NASA only provided advice. He said a Chilean Navy doctor later told him that most of the recommendations were used in the final design.

The Smithsonian’s report says the finished capsule carried audio and video links so each miner could talk to the surface, sensors to monitor heart rate and other functions, an emergency oxygen supply, and a trapdoor that could drop out the bottom, with a rope, in case the capsule got stuck. Cragg described the thinking in his oral history: the engineers wanted lighting and two-way communication to help diagnose problems, while the doctors wanted the same features for morale and to talk with a miner who had a medical issue.

The Moment Everything Changed

When the Plan B drill broke through on 9 October, the rescue changed from an engineering project into a schedule.

The capsule had arrived on 25 September, painted in the colours of the Chilean flag, and was tested on 30 September. Two additional capsules and a winch arrived on 6 October. On 12 October, Mining Minister Laurence Golborne announced that the rescue was expected to begin in the last quarter of the day.

The first miner, 31-year-old Florencio Ávalos, reached the surface just after midnight Eastern time on 13 October, according to CNN. Luis Urzúa, the shift foreman, was the 33rd and last. CNN says that was about 22 and a half hours after the operation began, which works out to an average of roughly 40 minutes per man. The Smithsonian says the trip up took 10 to 15 minutes.

That is faster than the planners expected. Cragg recalled that when NASA’s team was at the site, people there estimated the extraction would take between one and four hours per person, so the team designed with a long, confined trip in mind. He said that, as the operation went on and the crews saw the design perform, they sped up.

What Would Have Happened Without the Technology?

The honest answer is that the sources do not let us say.

What the sources do show is the problem. The men were more than 2,000 feet down under a collapsed ramp, and the first holes were too small to carry a person. Officials had expected the rescue could stretch to November or Christmas, and Plan B reached the miners with a wide enough hole on 9 October, about five weeks after it arrived on 3 September. Without a way to widen a hole that deep, and a vehicle small enough to travel it, there would have been no route out.

But the technology did not act alone, and it did not work before people did. The miners had survived 17 days with almost no outside contact, and Dr. Polk credited their shift leader’s organisation of water. Cragg said that when the time came for the rescue, “it was a Chilean show.” He also credited the Chilean government for asking for help from several countries: he mentions an American team for Plan B, a Canadian team for Plan C, and help from Australians, South Africans and Germans.

The Technology Behind the Breakthrough

Several technologies had to come together, and one of them was medicine.

Water-well drilling, adapted. A rig normally used to bore holes for water was turned into the machine that opened the way. According to Center Rock, which supplied the bits, Plan B began with the 5.5-inch hole that had first found the miners alive, opened it to 12 inches, and then widened it to 26 inches, which was big enough for the capsule.

A supply line. Cragg described how food and other items were sent down narrow boreholes in a device called a paloma (Spanish for dove): a two-metre pipe capped at both ends and lowered on a winch. When he timed one descent, it took eight minutes and 22 seconds.

Space medicine. NASA’s physicians described several lessons from long spaceflight that they passed on. Dr. Polk said in his oral history that after 17 days of starvation, feeding had to restart “low and slow,” beginning at 500 calories and rising gradually, because a sudden carbohydrate load can be dangerous for someone who has been starving. He said the miners were also moved off bare hot rock onto cots, to help protect their kidneys from muscle breakdown. Dr. Michael Duncan, the NASA team’s leader, said astronauts and the miners share a vitamin D problem when they go without sunlight for long periods, and that the miners were advised to drink extra fluid before the ascent, a technique used with returning astronauts. Polk added that they exercised before the rescue, wore a tight compression garment under their clothes, and wore sunglasses, because they had not been exposed to sunlight for months.

These accounts come from NASA physicians’ interviews, and they describe advice given to the Chilean medical team, not decisions NASA made.

Where the Technology Is Today

This article describes the rescue as it happened in 2010. I did not research how mine rescue works today, so I will not make claims about it.

What the sources do show is that this was an unusual cooperation at the time. NASA’s Administrator and Deputy Administrator honoured the team members at a ceremony on 28 October 2010. The test capsule, Fénix 1, was later put on display at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History.

The Limits

The rescue worked, and it is still a story with limits.

  • NASA did not design the capsule. NASA’s own history page says its team provided technical advice and an engineering requirements document, and Cragg says the Chileans did the design and the building.
  • Technology did not prevent the collapse. It retrieved people after the fact. CNN reports that Chilean prosecutors closed the investigation into the disaster in August 2013 without filing any charges, and that the mine’s owner agreed to sell the mine to pay the miners and repay the government’s rescue costs.
  • Every method carried risk. NASA engineer Michael Aguilar told the Smithsonian the team asked what would happen if a miner got stuck, which is why the capsule has a trapdoor and a rope.
  • Small differences between sources. Capsule dimensions, drill details and timings vary between accounts, and I have used the Smithsonian and CNN figures where they differ.

What Comes Next?

Already established: parallel rescue plans, narrow supply boreholes that become a lifeline, capsules sized to the hole, and medical protocols for long confinement, all documented above.

Not claimed here: I have not found a verified source for future technology in mine rescue, so I am not making any predictions.

Conclusion

The men who came up from the San José mine were the same men who had gone down. They had spent 69 days at the bottom of a hole, and what changed in those weeks was how much was known about them: first a note, then a pipe with food, then a way to talk to them, then a drill normally used for water wells.

Technology did not save them by itself. They survived the first 17 days on their own, and the people above ground spent the 52 days that followed drilling toward them. The story would not have ended the way it did without a drill that could reach that deep and a capsule that fit through the hole. For about a day, a steel capsule 21 inches wide was the way out.

Sources

Source Type Published What it supports
2010 Chilean Mine Rescue Fast Facts, CNN Library (copy on WRAL.com) Established news organization (fact timeline) Page undated; includes events to 2015 Timeline from 5 August to 13 October 2010; Plans A, B and C and their drills; note from the miners; probe dates; capsule arrival and test; first and last miners; 22.5 hours; baby Esperanza; prosecutors closing the case in 2013
The Capsule That Saved the Chilean Miners, Smithsonian Magazine (Joseph Stromberg) Museum / magazine January 2012 Capsule dimensions (13 ft by 21 in), features (audio/video, sensors, oxygen, trapdoor), Fénix 1 and 2, 10 to 15 minute ascent, eighth exploratory drill and note, NESC involvement
Chilean Miners Rescue Oral Histories, NASA History Office U.S. government agency Interviews conducted in 2011 NASA team members and dates on site (30 August to 5 September 2010), scope of NASA’s help, 69 days, 17 days to find survivors, honours ceremony 28 October 2010
NASA oral history, Clinton H. Cragg, 23 June 2011 (PDF on nasa.gov) U.S. government agency, first-hand interview 2011 NASA engineering role, requirements document, Chilean design and build, other national teams, one to four hour estimate, paloma timing
NASA oral history, J. Michael Duncan, 3 August 2011 (PDF on nasa.gov) U.S. government agency, first-hand interview 2011 Vitamin D, fluid loading before ascent, team role
NASA oral history, James D. Polk, 27 May 2011 (PDF on nasa.gov) U.S. government agency, first-hand interview 2011 Re-feeding protocol, cots, wells dug by the shift leader, compression garment, sunglasses
Chilean Miners Rescue (Rescue 33), Center Rock Inc. Company page (manufacturer’s own account) October 2010 How the pneumatic hammer drill worked, 9 October breakthrough; used only for the description of the drill, with attribution

Other pages consulted, a Global Mining Review retrospective, an Engineering & Mining Journal article on Plan B and an American Petroleum Institute blog post, could not be opened when this article was written, so none of them is cited.

Editorial Disclaimer

This article is an independent editorial work for Tech Horizon City’s “Technology That Changed Lives” series, based on the publicly available sources listed above. Where sources disagree, the article says so. NASA oral histories record personal recollections and, as NASA notes, personal opinions expressed in them are not the official views of NASA. If any factual error is identified, Tech Horizon City will correct it promptly after verification.

📚 Keep learning: If this kind of technology fascinates you, check out CramVaultFix — exam-prep flashcards and study guides for nursing, medical coding, standardized tests, and more.

Keep reading

Translate »
Scroll to Top